When I Do Header

Understanding Your Vehicle’s Safety Ratings

Apofeozzz/depositphoto

Between horsepower specs, infotainment features, and the color of the leather seats, it’s easy to get distracted when shopping for a car. But if there's one thing you shouldn’t gloss over in the glossy brochure, it’s the safety rating. After all, cars can be fun, fast, and fuel-efficient—but when it comes to a collision, what you really want is a vehicle that protects you like a rolling suit of armor.

So what exactly are safety ratings? Who assigns them? And what do those stars and acronyms actually mean when you’re comparing one model to another?

Let’s break it down so you can understand what’s behind those numbers—and how to choose a vehicle that won’t just get you there, but get you there safely.

Who Tests Vehicle Safety?

In the U.S., two major organizations lead the charge on crash tests and vehicle safety ratings:

🚗 NHTSA (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration)

This is the government agency responsible for highway safety. NHTSA conducts frontal, side, and rollover crash tests, then assigns a star rating from 1 to 5 (with 5 being the safest). Their system is straightforward and easily digestible, perfect for quick comparisons.

🚙 IIHS (Insurance Institute for Highway Safety)

This is an independent, non-profit organization funded by the insurance industry. IIHS is known for more rigorous and detailed testing, rating vehicles as Good, Acceptable, Marginal, or Poor across various crash scenarios. They also name Top Safety Pick and Top Safety Pick+ winners each year for vehicles that meet high standards across the board.

What Are They Testing For, Exactly?

Here’s a closer look at the kinds of crash and safety tests these organizations perform:

1. Frontal Crash Tests

  • NHTSA crashes vehicles head-on into a barrier at 35 mph.
  • IIHS performs both moderate overlap and small overlap frontal crash tests. The small overlap test, introduced in 2012, simulates what happens when the front corner of a car hits a pole or another vehicle—something that can severely compromise the structural integrity of the cabin.

2. Side Impact Tests

  • Simulate being hit by another vehicle at an intersection.
  • IIHS now uses a larger, heavier barrier to better represent real-world SUV and truck impacts.

3. Rollover Resistance (NHTSA only)

  • Measures the likelihood of a vehicle tipping during a sharp turn or evasive maneuver.

4. Roof Strength (IIHS only)

  • Tests how well the roof supports weight in the event of a rollover—important for SUVs and crossovers.

5. Head Restraint and Seat Performance

  • Evaluates how well the seat and headrest protect against whiplash injuries during a rear-end crash.

6. Crash Avoidance & Mitigation

  • This is where tech comes into play:Automatic emergency braking (AEB)Forward collision warning (FCW)Lane departure warning (LDW)Pedestrian detection systemsIIHS scores these systems as Basic, Advanced, or Superior based on how well they prevent or reduce crash severity.

What the Ratings Really Mean for You

A car with top-tier safety ratings doesn’t mean you’re invincible, but it does mean you’ll likely walk away from a crash you might not have in another vehicle. Here’s what to consider:

  • Don’t just look at the stars. Dig into what kind of crash tests the vehicle aced—or flubbed. Some cars do well in frontal crashes but underperform in side-impact or small-overlap tests.
  • Technology matters. A high score in crash prevention tech can sometimes be as important as how a car handles a collision. After all, the safest crash is the one you avoid altogether.
  • Size still plays a role. In general, larger vehicles tend to fare better in multi-vehicle crashes, simply due to physics. However, smaller cars with excellent safety design can still be incredibly safe.
  • Top Safety Pick ≠ Top Safety Pick+. That “plus” means the vehicle also scored well in headlight performance—an often overlooked but crucial safety factor when driving at night.

Where to Check Safety Ratings

Before you buy, check your vehicle’s safety ratings here:

  • nhtsa.gov/ratings
  • iihs.org

Both sites are searchable by make, model, and year—and they offer side-by-side comparisons, crash footage, and explanations that go beyond marketing fluff.

The Bottom Line

Understanding vehicle safety ratings isn’t just about data—it’s about choosing peace of mind. It's the difference between hoping your car will protect you and knowing it has the engineering to back it up.

So while you’re weighing your options between heated seats and panoramic sunroofs, remember: the real luxury is being protected when it matters most. Because when life hits hard (literally), those stars and scores are the unsung heroes you’ll be glad you took seriously.