When I Do Header

Comparing Gasoline Grades: Does It Really Matter?

whitestar1955/depositphoto

There you are at the gas pump, staring at three different buttons—regular, mid-grade, and premium—each one just a little more expensive than the last. Maybe you glance around to see what other drivers are selecting. Maybe you squint at your gas cap. And maybe, just maybe, you press the middle one, thinking, “Eh, can’t hurt, right?”

But here’s the real question: does it actually make a difference? Is premium gas really better for your car, or is it just high-octane marketing?

Let’s pop the fuel flap on this mystery.

Octane 101: What Those Numbers Actually Mean

The numbers you see at the pump—usually 87 (regular), 89 (mid-grade), and 91 or 93 (premium)—refer to octane rating, a measure of a fuel’s ability to resist “knocking” or “pinging” during combustion. Higher octane = more resistance.

That knocking? It’s not your engine’s death rattle (yet), but it’s definitely not ideal. It happens when fuel combusts too early in the engine’s cycle, potentially causing performance issues over time. Higher-octane fuel prevents that premature combustion, which is why certain engines require premium fuel—they’re built with higher compression ratios or turbocharging that demands it.

But here’s the twist: most engines don’t need premium fuel. If your car is designed to run on regular, using a higher octane won’t make it run faster, cleaner, or better. It won’t boost your horsepower. It won’t stretch your gas mileage. And it definitely won’t extend the life of your engine. It just... burns.

What the Manufacturer Says Matters Most

Your car’s owner's manual is the fuel gospel. If it says “regular unleaded,” that’s what your engine is optimized for. Using premium won’t hurt it, but it will hurt your wallet, and the performance benefits will be virtually nonexistent.

Now, if your manual says “premium recommended” (a favorite phrase in high-end or performance cars), that’s a bit of a gray area. It means your car can run on regular, but it’ll perform a little better—smoother acceleration, maybe a smidge more power—on premium. In this case, you won’t damage anything by using 87 octane, but you might not be getting your engine’s full potential either.

If it says “premium required”? That’s non-negotiable. Using regular in a premium-required engine can lead to knocking, reduced performance, and over time, possible engine damage. Saving a few bucks per fill-up today could cost you big later.

Mid-Grade: The Awkward Middle Child

Mid-grade fuel often exists more for pump design than performance. It’s rarely required by vehicles and is usually a blend of regular and premium created at the nozzle. Unless your car explicitly calls for 89 octane (some do), you’re better off committing to regular or premium based on your engine’s needs.

Are There Situations Where Premium Might Help?

If you’re towing heavy loads, driving in high-altitude environments, or have a high-performance engine that’s knocking even on recommended fuel, premium might help. But for your average sedan, crossover, or economy car? The benefits are psychological at best.

Fuel Quality Isn’t Just About Octane

While we’re here: don’t confuse fuel quality with fuel grade. What you should care about is whether your gas station provides Top Tier™ gasoline—a standard backed by automakers that ensures a higher level of detergent additives to keep your engine clean. Many major brands qualify. You can check for the Top Tier logo or look it up online.

You could be filling up with regular gas at one station and premium at another—and the regular might actually be betterif it meets Top Tier standards.

So, What’s the Verdict?

  • If your car says regular, use regular. Don’t pay more for premium unless you like giving your money away.
  • If it says premium recommended, you can use regular without worry, though premium might give you a slight edge.
  • If it says premium required, listen to your engine and give it the good stuff.
  • Skip mid-grade unless your car specifically calls for it.
  • Focus on Top Tier fuel quality over octane if you care about long-term engine health.

The Bottom Line

Octane is important—but only if your engine calls for it. Choosing the right gasoline grade isn’t about treating your car to a luxury spa day. It’s about giving it the fuel it was designed to use. In most cases, that’s regular unleaded. So next time you're at the pump, take a breath, skip the guilt, and press the button that makes sense for your engine—not your ego.

Your car (and your budget) will thank you.